Skip to content
Hub Nexus

No author yetClaim it

Version 1Updated 6 min read

Support

This is an analysis of the journal article “Effects of one year of resistance training on the relation between muscular strength and bone density in elderly women” by E C Rhodes, A D Martin, J E Taunton, M Donnelly, J Warren, J Elliot (1999).[1] The Wikibook review has been created by u3096476 as a part of an assignment for the unit Health Disease and Exercise at the University of Canberra.

Osteoporosis Locations (Image: BruceBlaus, CC BY-SA 4.0)

What Is The Background To This Research?

Osteoporosis in the elderly society is a deadly chronic condition that silently affects people until diagnosed or too late. Recent research has linked progressive resistance exercise (PRE) to strengthening bones and muscles and supposedly slowing the effects of Osteoporosis.[1]

What is Osteoporosis?

Osteoporosis is a common chronic condition that causes bones to become brittle and weak by losing their density.[2] This condition affects 70% of people over 80 and around 15% of Caucasian people over 50. Women are more susceptible to the condition as estrogen (a hormone that protects bones) rapidly decrease after menopause which causes bone lose. This leads to an increase chance of bones becoming fractured which is a serious problem for elderly people as it can cause chronic pain, disability or even premature death.[3]

The purpose of this research was to investigate the long term effects of resistance training on dynamic muscular strength and bone mineral density (BMD) on elderly women. The study is based on the Wolff’s Law theory of bone modeling which states that “a bone in a healthy person or animal will adapt to the loads under which it is placed”.[4]

Where Is The Research From?

The study was conducted in the following facilities listed below

  • School of Human Kinetics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
  • Allan McGavin Sports Medicine Center
  • STAT Unit, Vancouver Hospital and Health Sciences Center, Vancouver

Correspondence to: Dr E C Rhodes, School of Human Kinetics, War Memorial Gymnasium, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z1, Canada.[1]

What Kind Of Research Was This?

This study was a case control study. Case control studies are retrospective and aim to observe and measure a population with a specific illness or disease (Case) and then compare them with populations without the disease (Control).[5]

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Useful at establishing associationsRetrospective, thus having to recall data can lead to error.
Good for studying illness & diseaseFinding control groups can be difficult
Typically inexpensiveTypically, randomized controlled trials provide better evidence.

Age and bone mass

Age and bone mass (Image: Anatomy & Physiology, Connexions Web site. http://cnx.org/content/col11496/1.6/ , CC BY 3.0)

What Did The Research Involve?

  • 44 participants to meet criteria and take medical screenings
  • Voluntary split into two groups (exercise and control)
  • Control continued daily lifestyle and exercisers trained PRE for 52 weeks
  • Weights lifted a rate of 75% 1 repetition maximum (RM) for 3 sets of 8 repetitions
  • Fully supervised with regular check ups
  • Targeting major muscle groups
  • Grip strength, skin folds and flexibility measures were recorded
  • BMD measured with dual x-ray absorptiometry (Lunar DPX).[1]

What Were The Basic Results?

Basic results showed increases in muscle strength increases that ranged from 19 to 53% in exercises. In conjunction with the strength gains it showed significant changes in BMD in the femoral and lumbar region.[1] Analysis of covariance was used for statistics and it showed large strength gains (p<0.01) in bilateral bench press (>29%), bilateral leg press (>19%) and unilateral biceps curl (>20%).[1] There were no significant changes in flexibility, grip strength or anthropometry in either groups which was believed to be because the exercise regime focused on strength, which resulted in little change to body composition or flexibility. Strength gains and BMD were almost parallel with changes in dynamic leg strength and femoral neck, Ward’s triangle and the lumbar spine.[1]

Table: Pre and Post changes in BMD in the Femoral Neck.[1]

ExerciseControl
Pre (mean)Post (mean)Pre (mean)Post (mean)
BMC (g)3.97 (0.21)4.02 (0.22)3.71 (0.27)3.48 (0.19)
Area (cm2)4.82 (0.30)4.87 (0.28)4.81 (0.28)4.78 (0.22)
BMD (g/cm2)0.82 (0.11)0.83 (0.12)0.78 (0.09)0.73 (0.10)

BMC=Bone mineral content

There were some limitations to the study as after 3 months of supervised exercise, the groups were ordered to self-report their exercises in a log book in which 86% of the exercise subjects regularly attended sessions which is still a good figure.[1] Retrospective data needs to be recalled and errors can occur i.e. Subjects overestimating results to cut corners in exercise. Regardless, there is a certain relationship between resistance training and bone mineral density; with regular exercise and constant recalibration of weights there is a very strong suggestion that it could slow the effects of osteoporosis.[1]

How Did The Researchers Interpret The Results?

These results were interpreted by the researchers as a clear indication that PRE in elderly woman would improve functional capacity and slow the progression of osteoporosis. There would be less chance of falls from strength gains and less chance of breaks due to greater BMD.[1] This would inevitably mean that the elderly would be able to continue to live independently and would result in a better quality of life.[6]

What Conclusions Should Be Taken Away From This Research?

There have been serval similar studies on elderly subjects and strength training which have had very similar or better signs on strength gains. Unfortunately, literature in the same area of study has failed to draw a significant link between muscle strength and its influence on bone density.[1] Some principles of maintaining bone density didn’t make sense as theoretically a muscle contraction would directly reflect on the skeletal sight. Where as results stated that “Although the anatomical origin of the quadriceps muscle groups is not on the lumbar spine, the agonist/antagonist effects of the hip flexors and the knee flexors would directly impact the lumbar spine”.[1]

The researches stated that the effects of PRE on BMD is still inconclusive as the results from the data were not statically significant although they did show positive changes. As bone growth is also slow they agreed that in order to see significant changes in bone growth, one year of exercise might be insufficient and the training periods would need to be extended.[1]

What Are The Implications Of This Research?

This research has shown exercise interventions appear to be beneficial in delaying the onset of osteoporosis. However further research needs to be conducted to understand physiologically how this is of benefit and how to best implement strategies to reduce the onset of osteoporosis.[1]

Further reading

For more information on the effects of osteoporosis and the benefits of exercise use the following links, alternatively contact your GP for additional information.

References

Where this page came from

This page was imported from Wikibooks. From “Exercise as it relates to Disease” on Wikibooks, by its contributors, under CC BY-SA 4.0. Changed here: set as a page; navigation and edit links left out; each image under its own licence, credited in its caption.

Nobody has written it yet — it is the source material at a new address, which is why search engines are asked to skip it and why no one earns from it. It is up for grabs: take it on, and it is yours to rewrite and to earn from.

Comments

Spinner Logo

Next in Exercise as it relates to Disease

CC BY-SA 4.0
This is a student analysis of a study by Gomes et al. (2015).[1] The topic of this research is "Active Video Game Exercise Training Improves the Clinical Control of Asthma in Children: Randomised Controlled Trial".[1] ## What is the background to this research? Asthma is a lung condition whereby the
CC BY-SA 4.0
This review was completed for the unit Health Disease and Exercise at the University of Canberra and explores the relationship between exercise and increased quality of life for Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) patients.[1] This is a critique of the paper: Wootton, S.L., et al., Ground-b
CC BY-SA 4.0
This Wikibooks page is a fact sheet and analysis on the article "Habitual physical activity in children and adolescents with cystic fibrosis" about how exercise is related to the disease Cystic Fibrosis. ## Background of this research The research was about the effects of taking part in exercise con
CC BY-SA 4.0
This is an analysis of the study "Regular physical activity reduces hospital admission and mortality in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a population based cohort study" by Anto, Benet, Garcia-Aymerich, Lange and Schnohr (2006).[1] ## What is the background to this research? The World Health O
CC BY-SA 4.0
**This fact sheet is in reference to the article:** ‘Short-Term Effect of Different Physical Exercises and Physiotherapy Combinations on Sputum Expectoration, Oxygen Saturation, and Lung Function in Young Patients with Cystic Fibrosis.’ [1] Created by u3099790. ## Background Cystic Fibrosis (CF) is
CC BY-SA 4.0
The following Wikibooks page is an analysis of “low physical fitness in childhood is associated with the development of asthma in young adulthood: the Odense schoolchild study” by Rasmussen et al. (2000) [1] ## What is the background to this research? Exercise has been shown to enhance lung growth i